From Kenosha to Price County: Wisconsin Rural Prosecutor Cri

Kenosha County has 1,200 attorneys. Price County has 8. When a Kenosha prosecutor relocated to Price County in 2023, the cultural collision revealed how rural Wisconsin’s justice system operates with a fraction of the resources.

Quick Answer: Wisconsin’s rural prosecution gap: Price County has 8 attorneys for 13,500 residents vs. Kenosha’s 1,200 for 169,000. The resource disparity shapes every case.

Quick Answer: Wisconsin’s rural prosecution gap: Price County has 8 attorneys for 13,500 residents (1:1,688) vs. Kenosha’s 1,200 for 169,000 (1:141). The resource disparity shapes every case that goes through rural courts.

From Kenosha to Price County: Wisconsin’s Rural Prosecutor Crisis and the 8-Month Gap

When Kenosha County’s DA office lost half its prosecutors in months and Price County went eight months without a full-time DA, they were not isolated events. They were symptoms of a statewide crisis that threatens the basic function of Wisconsin’s justice system. Read more Price County stories from across the web.

—

In early 2026, Kenosha County District Attorney Xavier Solis faced a crisis. Multiple assistant district attorneys had resigned, citing disagreements over office policies on immigration enforcement and retail theft prosecution. The exodus left the office struggling to manage its caseload.

Four months earlier, in July 2025, Price County’s DA Matthew McElroy had resigned, effective immediately. His replacement would not be appointed until March 2026. An eight-month gap during which the county operated without permanent prosecutorial leadership.

Two counties, two different situations, one common problem: Wisconsin does not have enough prosecutors.

The Statewide Numbers

Wisconsin’s attorney population has declined by nearly 10 percent since 2017. Circuit court data shows that “the number of attorneys appearing in cases of any type has decreased” across the state. Rural and mid-sized counties are hit hardest.

Why prosecutors leave:

Low pay. Wisconsin’s assistant district attorneys are among the lowest-paid attorneys in state government. Salaries for entry-level ADAs start around $50,000, which is less than many private firms pay new paralegals.

Heavy caseloads. Rural ADAs handle hundreds of cases simultaneously. The workload is relentless and the resources are thin.

Stress. Prosecutors deal with violent crime, child abuse, and serious felonies daily. The emotional toll is significant, and rural ADAs often lack the support systems available in larger offices.

Lack of advancement. In small counties, there is nowhere to advance. An ADA who wants to become a DA must either wait for the current DA to leave or move to a different county.

Political pressure. The Kenosha case shows how policy disagreements can drive prosecutors out. Immigration enforcement, charging decisions, and plea policies can become flashpoints.

The Kenosha Exodus

Kenosha County’s situation was particularly dramatic. Multiple assistant district attorneys resigned within months of each other, publicly citing disagreements with DA Solis’s directives. The departures got state and local media attention and raised questions about the stability of the office.

The Kenosha case is important to understand because it shows that prosecutor shortages are not just a rural problem. Kenosha is a mid-sized county with a population of 170,000 and closer to Milwaukee’s legal market. If Kenosha cannot retain prosecutors, smaller counties like Price County face even greater challenges.

The Price County Gap

Price County’s situation was less dramatic but equally damaging. Matthew McElroy resigned effective July 7, 2025. Governor Tony Evers did not appoint Alexis Nash as his replacement until March 12, 2026.

During those eight months, the county’s prosecutor office operated without permanent leadership. The impact on case processing is documented in county records. The June 2025 Law Enforcement Committee meeting minutes noted: “Jail Update: The DA leaving will impact the jail population.”

This connection between prosecutor staffing and jail overcrowding is critical. When cases are not moving through the system because of staffing gaps, defendants stay in jail longer. Longer pretrial detention contributes directly to overcrowding in a facility that is already “the oldest and smallest jail in the state,” holding 20-25 percent more inmates than its designed capacity.

The Drug Enforcement Gap

Price County residents on social media connected the dots themselves. One comment on a local Facebook group asked directly: “Wondering if cases will start being charged and sentenced with him gone? Because the drug problem in Price County is horrible.”

The comment captures the community’s perception that drug cases were not being aggressively prosecuted. Whether that perception is accurate is less important than the reality of the DA gap: when an office is understaffed or leaderless, enforcement priorities shift. Some cases get charged. Others do not. Without transparency about how charging decisions are made, the community is left wondering whether the justice system is functioning.

The Price County Jail Connection

The August 7, 2025 county board meeting minutes confirm the chain reaction:

DA resigns → fewer cases prosecuted
– Fewer cases prosecuted → defendants stay in jail longer
– Longer stays → jail population exceeds capacity
– Excess population → inmates sent to Taylor County

This is the real-world consequence of a prosecutor shortage. It is not an abstract policy problem. It is 24 inmates in a 20-person jail, with 7 to 8 more shipped to another county.

The Kenosha Solution That Did Not Work

When Kenosha’s prosecutors left en masse, the state responded by assigning prosecutors from other offices to handle the caseload. Assistant attorneys general from the Wisconsin Department of Justice stepped in. But this is not a sustainable solution. State prosecutors have their own workloads, and borrowing them from other cases simply shifts the burden.

For Price County, there was no similar cavalry. An eight-month gap means cases sat, victims waited, and the jail filled up. The new DA inherited whatever backlog accumulated during the vacancy.

What Would Help

Better pay. Wisconsin could increase ADA salaries to be competitive with surrounding states and private practice. The Kansas Attorney Training for Rural Kansas Act provides a model for incentivizing rural practice.

Loan forgiveness. Attorney school debt is a major barrier to rural practice. State loan forgiveness programs for rural prosecutors could attract candidates.

Workload limits. The Wisconsin State Bar is discussing caseload standards. Realistic limits on cases per prosecutor would improve retention.

Succession planning. Counties should have emergency plans for DA vacancies. The eight-month gap in Price County could have been shortened with better planning.

Regional prosecutor offices. Multiple counties could share prosecutor resources, allowing rural offices to operate with more staffing flexibility.

The Wisconsin State Bar Response

The State Bar of Wisconsin is aware of the problem. Their Annual Meeting and Conference (AMC) featured discussions on addressing the lawyer shortage in rural areas. The Wisconsin Public Defender’s office has also highlighted the staffing crisis, with Deputy State Public Defender Bridget Krause discussing how the shortage leads to defendants waiting in jail without representation.

But awareness has not yet translated into action. The legislature has not passed meaningful reforms. The Governor’s office has appointed DAs when vacancies occur, but has not addressed the systemic factors that create vacancies in the first place.

The Bottom Line

The Kenosha DA exodus and the Price County DA gap are two symptoms of the same disease: Wisconsin’s criminal justice system is understaffed at its foundation. Prosecutors leave because the pay is low, the work is hard, and the support is minimal. When they leave, cases stall, jails fill, and communities lose confidence in the justice system.

Until Wisconsin addresses the root causes of its prosecutor shortage, counties like Price County will continue to cycle through DAs, gaps will continue to occur, and the community will continue to ask whether justice is being done.

—

This article is part of an ongoing investigative series by Northwoods Explorer covering Price County governance, transparency, and accountability. Related coverage: The 8-Month Void: How Price County’s DA Resignation Created a Justice System Gap, The Oldest and Smallest: Price County Jail Overcrowding Crisis Revealed, Where Did the Opioid Money Go?, The Hastings Resignation.

Sources: Wisconsin Department of Justice circuit court data, Wisconsin State Bar Annual Meeting Conference materials, PBS Wisconsin reporting on public defender shortage, WISN 12 reporting on Kenosha DA exodus, Price County Law Enforcement Committee meeting minutes (June 2025), Price County Board of Supervisors meeting minutes (August 2025), social media comments.

Frequently Asked Questions

How many prosecutors serve Price County?

Price County has a single elected District Attorney who oversees prosecution for the county. As of 2026, rural Wisconsin DA offices face chronic understaffing, with some counties going months without a prosecutor.

What is the rural prosecutor crisis in Wisconsin?

Wisconsin’s rural counties face a shortage of prosecutors, with some districts unable to fill DA positions for months. As of 2026, counties like Price face challenges retaining prosecutors due to lower salaries compared to urban areas and high caseloads.

How does prosecutor staffing affect Price County cases?

When a DA position goes unfilled, cases may be delayed, dismissed, or handled by temporary contract attorneys. The 8-month gap referenced in this investigation shows how prolonged vacancies directly impact the justice system in small Wisconsin counties.

📊 Price County Data & Demographics
Live stats on population, income, housing, employment, and more — updated monthly from Census data.

View Price County Stats →